Collaboration
Critswap
Landing page and product crits from fellow makers
- Category
- Collaboration
- Stage
- Beta
- For
- Makers seeking structured feedback on landing pages or products
About
Find out what other makers really think of your landing page. Free: you tell one of them what you think of theirs first. About two minutes each.
Features
- Problem
- Feedback can be vague and difficult to act on.
- How it works
- Each crit follows three fixed parts: first impression, rating, and an answer to one maker-defined question.
- Result
- More actionable feedback on a landing page or product.
- Why
- A consistent structure lets makers compare crits, identify patterns, and understand the reasons behind ratings.
- Problem
- Makers need a straightforward way to earn feedback.
- How it works
- Sending a crit earns one Echo; one Echo pays for one crit on the member’s own project.
- Result
- Members can trade review effort for feedback.
- Why
- The one-for-one currency keeps the exchange simple rather than rewarding points farming.
- Problem
- A maker may not have time to review others’ pages.
- How it works
- Members can buy Echo at the current listed price, and bought Echo works like earned Echo.
- Result
- Feedback remains accessible during time-constrained periods.
- Why
- The product supports either contributing time or paying for credits.
- Problem
- Not every submitted page is suitable to review.
- How it works
- Members can skip pages that are broken, empty, or outside what they can judge.
- Result
- Crits are better matched to pages reviewers can assess.
- Why
- Reviews should be written only when the reviewer can genuinely speak to the page.
- Problem
- Makers may not want their project publicly listed.
- How it works
- Pages are shown only to members while they are giving crits.
- Result
- Feedback can be sought without placement on a public list.
- Why
- The service keeps project exposure within the member review flow.
Product questions
What does Critswap do?
Critswap is a feedback exchange for makers: give a structured crit on another member’s landing page or product to earn a crit on your own project, or buy credits instead.
Who is Critswap for?
Makers seeking structured feedback on landing pages or products